November 19, 2026
Dec. 2 will mark the 46th anniversary of the murders of four American church women in El Salvador. Two of them – Ursuline Sister Dorothy Kazel and missionary Jean Donovan – were from the Diocese of Cleveland. The others were Maryknoll missionaries Sister Maura Clarke and Sister Ita Ford.
A documentary revisiting the 1980 murders, “The Killing of Sister Dorothy,” will be released on Amazon Prime on Nov. 26.
Filmmakers – and brothers – Andrew Arehart, Jack Arehart and Matthew Arehart said the documentary is an opportunity to introduce a new generation to the lives and legacy of the four women who were serving vulnerable communities during El Salvador’s civil war. In 1964, the Diocese of Cleveland established – and still operates – a mission in El Salvador.
The film examines the events through the perspectives of Sister Kazel, Sister Ford, Sister Clarke, and Donovan, using Sister Kazel’s previously unheard recordings, as well as the memories of the family, friends and fellow religious who knew them.
At the center of the series is a collection of archival material. The Church’s preserved recordings, photos and videos offer new insight into the four martyred women’s faith, lives, work and deaths. Through her personal cassette recordings, Sister Kazel documented the violence that would ultimately claim her own life.
Directed by Andrew Arehart, Jack Arehart, and Matthew Arehart, the documentary combines the archival material with firsthand accounts and interviews to tell the story of Sister Kazel’s faith and service, as well as the political and social violence that led to the four women’s abductions and murders. It highlights this chapter in El Salvador’s history, the international public outrage at the women’s deaths, and the lasting impact of their work and faith.
The Arehart Brothers are from Northeast Ohio. They are writers, directors, producers and editors who studied film at Cleveland State University. Their short films have screened at numerous international film festivals, including the Cleveland International Film Festival and the International Family Film Festival.
The brothers’ connection to “The Killing of Sister Dorothy” began in childhood, when they first heard the story of Sister Kazel and the three churchwomen from their great-aunt, an Ursuline nun who was a friend of Sister Kazel’s. Years later, they turned the story into a 12-minute documentary for their thesis project at film school. That collaboration ultimately became “The Killing of Sister Dorothy,” a four-part documentary series created collectively by the trio.
Click here for more information on Sister Kazel, Donovan, Sister Clarke and Sister Ford.